Official statement
Other statements from this video 12 ▾
- 1:00 Comment optimiser vos balises title pour éviter que Google ne les réécrive ?
- 1:34 Les meta descriptions influencent-elles vraiment le classement ou juste le CTR ?
- 2:05 Les balises heading sont-elles vraiment un signal de classement ou juste une béquille d'accessibilité ?
- 2:37 Les liens internes descriptifs sont-ils vraiment le levier SEO qu'on vous a vendu ?
- 3:11 Les données structurées améliorent-elles vraiment l'affichage dans les SERP ?
- 4:14 Le rapport de couverture d'index Search Console suffit-il vraiment à diagnostiquer vos problèmes d'indexation ?
- 4:46 Les statuts d'indexation Google : savez-vous vraiment interpréter « exclu » vs « valide » ?
- 5:17 Faut-il systématiquement valider les corrections d'indexation dans Search Console ?
- 5:47 Pourquoi soumettre un sitemap reste-t-il indispensable pour le crawl de votre site ?
- 6:52 Faut-il vraiment optimiser les snippets en se basant uniquement sur le CTR ?
- 6:52 Pourquoi vos requêtes cibles n'apparaissent-elles jamais dans la Search Console ?
- 6:52 Pourquoi vos pages stratégiques disparaissent-elles du rapport de performance Search Console ?
Google officially recommends three types of structured data: FAQ for pages containing frequently asked questions, How-to for step-by-step tutorials, and breadcrumbs to illustrate the site's hierarchy. This stance seems restrictive when one knows that Schema.org offers hundreds of types. Specifically, this means that these three formats likely receive priority treatment in the display of rich snippets, but it does not exempt you from implementing other relevant types for your business.
What you need to understand
Why does Google limit itself to three types of structured data?
This recommendation may come as a surprise when one considers the breadth of vocabulary offered by Schema.org. Google does not state that other types are useless but emphasizes those that generate the most value for users in search results.
FAQ allows questions and answers to be displayed directly in the SERP, increasing the space occupied by your result. How-to displays steps with sometimes thumbnail images. Breadcrumbs replace the green URL with a clickable breadcrumb trail, enhancing the understanding of the site's structure.
Is this list exhaustive or indicative?
Important nuance: Daniel Waisberg does not say these are the only types to implement but those Google recommends as a priority. Other types such as Product, Recipe, Event, or Article continue to function and generate rich snippets.
The difference? These three types are applicable to nearly all sites, regardless of their theme. They constitute a universal base, whereas others depend on the business context. An e-commerce site will need Product, a culinary blog will need Recipe — but all can benefit from breadcrumbs.
What impact does it have on the display in search results?
Implementing these structured data types does not guarantee their display; Google always reserves the right to ignore them. However, sites that properly integrate them generally see an improvement in click-through rates due to the visual enhancement of the results.
Breadcrumbs are consistently displayed when properly marked up. FAQs and How-tos depend more on the relevance of the query and the quality of the content. Google may choose to display only part of the FAQ questions or not display them at all if the content is deemed too promotional.
- Breadcrumbs improve the readability of the URL and the navigation context.
- FAQs increase the space occupied in the SERP and directly respond to search intentions.
- How-tos enhance tutorial content with detailed step displays.
- These three types are universal and applicable to most websites.
- Their correct implementation generally improves organic CTR.
SEO Expert opinion
Is this statement consistent with observations in the field?
Yes and no. In practice, it is observed that these three types indeed generate frequent and stable rich displays. Breadcrumbs typically work systematically, while FAQs appear regularly on informational queries.
However, limiting the recommendation to these three types ignores critical formats for certain sectors. E-commerce sites that neglect Product in favor of just FAQs/How-tos/Breadcrumbs may miss out on major gains. Media outlets without Article or NewsArticle cannot claim Top Stories treatment.
What nuances should be added to this recommendation?
Waisberg's statement likely addresses a general audience, not technical SEOs who already understand Schema.org. It aims to simplify the message for beginners who might get lost in the complexity of the vocabulary.
For a practitioner, the best approach is to implement all relevant types for your business — Product, LocalBusiness, Organization, Review, Event, etc. — then add these three recommended types as a complementary layer. [To be verified]: Google has never communicated a limit on the number of different Schema types on the same page, as long as they are consistent with the content.
What risks are there in following this recommendation to the letter?
A site that strictly limits itself to FAQs, How-tos, and breadcrumbs would miss out on significant opportunities. Product snippets display prices, availability, and reviews — essential for e-commerce. Recipe snippets generate massive traffic for culinary sites with cooking times, calories, etc.
Let's be honest: this recommendation resembles a prioritization message for limited resources, not an exhaustive list. If you have the time and skills to implement 8-10 relevant structured data types, do it. Focus on these three only if you need to choose a minimal starting point.
Practical impact and recommendations
What actionable steps should you take on your site?
Start with an audit of existing structured data. Use Google Search Console's rich results testing tool to identify what works and what generates errors. Check if your breadcrumbs are properly marked — this is often the easiest quick win.
Then, identify candidate pages for FAQs. Any page with a FAQ section can benefit: product sheets with customer FAQs, category pages with frequently asked questions, blog articles structured as Q&A. Be careful not to create artificial FAQs just for markup — Google penalizes content created solely for rich snippets.
How to implement these three types without risk?
For breadcrumbs, the JSON-LD format remains the easiest to maintain. Place the script in the
or just before the closing , with a list that accurately reflects the visible navigation. Ensure that each level has a valid and accessible URL.How-tos work well for tutorials, practical guides, recipes. Structure with HowToStep, including images when relevant. Google particularly appreciates time estimates (totalTime) and necessary tools (tool). Avoid applying this schema to content that is not truly a step-by-step guide — the algorithm detects inconsistencies.
What mistakes to avoid during implementation?
First classic mistake: duplicating FAQs across all pages with the same questions. Google values uniqueness — if 50 pages contain exactly the same FAQs, none will stand out. Personalize questions according to the context of each page.
Second pitfall: overloading a page with too many types of structured data without coherence. A product page can combine Product, Breadcrumb, and FAQ, but adding How-to without reason will create confusion. Stay relevant to the actual content of the page.
- Audit your existing structured data with Search Console and Google's testing tool.
- Implement breadcrumbs in JSON-LD on all pages that are more than one level deep.
- Identify 10-20 strategic pages to add contextual and unique FAQs.
- Apply How-tos only to real practical guides with clearly defined steps.
- Validate each implementation with the testing tool before production.
- Monitor the evolution of impressions and CTR in Search Console after deployment.
❓ Frequently Asked Questions
Faut-il abandonner les autres types de données structurées comme Product ou Article ?
Les breadcrumbs structurés améliorent-ils réellement le référencement ?
Peut-on mettre plusieurs FAQ sur la même page sans pénalité ?
Le markup How-to fonctionne-t-il pour tous les types de guides ?
Combien de temps avant de voir l'impact des données structurées dans la SERP ?
🎥 From the same video 12
Other SEO insights extracted from this same Google Search Central video · duration 9 min · published on 12/11/2020
🎥 Watch the full video on YouTube →
💬 Comments (0)
Be the first to comment.